Random reflections on culture, life and the Universe. Warning: will regularly include Scottish actors.
Tuesday, January 31, 2006
The bible retold
Great link from John at Counago&Spaves: hours of delight to be had from this site. But John is right: this one is a gem!
Oscars ahoy (incomplete post)
I never got chance to finish my response to the BAFTA nominations, and I'm a bit cross with myself for that because I don't like to just concentrate on the acting/directing categories. The behind-the-scenes stuff is also important, as is the writing. So here I have tried to address some of these but its still incomplete and I've a student due (after having a hideous time doing a workshop, not getting lunch till 3pm, and thankully a cancellation in my 3pm slot).
So here it is in all its incomplete ingloriousness: I hope to come back to it but you know what I'm like....
The nominations:
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE
Philip Seymour Hoffman - CAPOTE
Terrence Howard - HUSTLE & FLOW
Heath Ledger - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
Joaquin Phoenix - WALK THE LINE
David Strathairn - GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK.
I still rate Strathairn, but the swing may now be behind PSH for Capote, a film I am truly looking forward to seeing. Whilst for the BAFTAs you have to take account of the home vote for Fiennes, as well as the mixed desire to pre-empt the Oscars and reward those who may not get the Oscar look-in, in the US I think this may have now become more clear-cut.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
George Clooney - SYRIANA
Matt Dillon - CRASH
Paul Giamatti - CINDERELLA MAN
Jake Gyllenhaal - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
William Hurt - A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE
Not sure why Hurt is nominated for HoV: an old favourite back in favour with the academy? Paul Giamatti may swing this for losing out last year. Nice to see Crash getting nominations in abundance though, despite being last year's film rather than a more recent release for Oscar season.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A LEADING ROLE
Judi Dench - MRS. HENDERSON PRESENTS
Felicity Huffman - TRANSAMERICA
Keira Knightley - PRIDE & PREJUDICE
Charlize Theron - NORTH COUNTRY
Reese Witherspoon - WALK THE LINE
It seems as if Reese may be the hot favourite for this, closely followed by Felicity Huffman. It all depends on if they want to reward a musical in the acting nominations for the second year running (it's also why I don't think JP is front-runner for the actor award). If the two Brit nominations get whiff of this award I will scream "are you insane?" Prior winner Charlize Theron may lose out because of her winner status.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
Amy Adams - JUNEBUG
Catherine Keener - CAPOTE
Frances McDormand - NORTH COUNTRY
Rachel Weisz - THE CONSTANT GARDENER
Michelle Williams - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
I love Catherine Keener, but the swing may be behind Rachel Weisz for this one.
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE FILM OF THE YEAR
HOWL'S MOVING CASTLE
TIM BURTON'S CORPSE BRIDE
WALLACE & GROMIT IN THE CURSE OF THE WERE-RABBIT
Tough, tough, tough but my heart goes with W&G of course...
ACHIEVEMENT IN ART DIRECTION
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK Jim Bissell (Art Direction); Jan Pascale (Set Decoration)
HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE Stuart Craig (Art Direction); Stephenie McMillan (Set Decoration)
KING KONG Grant Major (Art Direction); Dan Hennah and Simon Bright (Set Decoration)
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA John Myhre (Art Direction); Gretchen Rau (Set Decoration)
PRIDE & PREJUDICE Sarah Greenwood (Art Direction); Katie Spencer (Set Decoration)
ACHIEVEMENT IN CINEMATOGRAPHY
BATMAN BEGINS Wally Pfister
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Rodrigo Prieto
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK Robert Elswit
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA Dion Beebe
THE NEW WORLD Emmanuel Lubezki
The look of a film can be so important, and all the director's vision in the world will not help if those making it look good (set, photography) are not equally matched to the director. In an age where we have grown used to colour, working in black and white always seems to look spectacularly wonderful on-screen, but getting it to look that way isn't easy: after all, we're not seeing the world in bloack and white through our eyes, and we're less used to critically comparing different black and white cinematography. Would it be a cop-out to reward the work then in GN&GL? I don't think so. Malik always seems to inspire good visuals though, so nice to see that getting a nod. I do admit though that Batman Begins did look amazing...
ACHIEVEMENT IN COSTUME DESIGN
CHARLIE AND THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
MRS. HENDERSON PRESENTS
PRIDE & PREJUDICE
WALK THE LINE
ACHIEVEMENT IN DIRECTING
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Ang Lee
CAPOTE Bennett Miller
CRASH Paul Haggis
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK George Clooney
MUNICH Steven Spielberg
Horrid to predict this one, except to say that I doubt Spielberg will scoop direction for Munich: but this is a very strong list with merit (or expectations of merit for those I've not yet seen) across the board in the category.
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE
DARWIN'S NIGHTMARE
ENRON: THE SMARTEST GUYS IN THE ROOM
MARCH OF THE PENGUINS
MURDERBALL
STREET FIGHT
BEST DOCUMENTARY SHORT SUBJECT
THE DEATH OF KEVIN CARTER: CASUALTY OF THE BANG BANG CLUB
GOD SLEEPS IN RWANDA
THE MUSHROOM CLUB
A NOTE OF TRIUMPH: THE GOLDEN AGE OF NORMAN CORWIN
ACHIEVEMENT IN FILM EDITING
CINDERELLA MAN Mike Hill and Dan Hanley
THE CONSTANT GARDENER Claire Simpson
CRASH Hughes Winborne
MUNICH Michael Kahn
WALK THE LINE Michael McCusker
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM OF THE YEAR
DON'T TELL
JOYEUX NOèL
PARADISE NOW
SOPHIE SCHOLL - THE FINAL DAYS
TSOTSI
ACHIEVEMENT IN MAKEUP
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE CINDERELLA MAN
STAR WARS: EPISODE III REVENGE OF THE SITH
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SCORE)
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
THE CONSTANT GARDENER
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
MUNICH
PRIDE & PREJUDICE
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SONG)
"In the Deep" - CRASH
"It's Hard Out Here for a Pimp" - HUSTLE & FLOW
"Travelin' Thru" - TRANSAMERICA
BEST MOTION PICTURE OF THE YEAR
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
CAPOTE
CRASH
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK
MUNICH
There was much speculation that Munich would not make much indentation on the Oscars this year - still at least they seemed to get the DVDs out to the voters. I suspect the weight is still behind Brokeback Mountain, though again this is a strong list.
BEST ANIMATED SHORT FILM
BADGERED THE MOON AND THE SON: AN IMAGINED CONVERSATION
THE MYSTERIOUS GEOGRAPHIC EXPLORATIONS OF JASPER MORELLO 9 ONE MAN BAND
BEST LIVE ACTION SHORT FILM
AUSREISSER (THE RUNAWAY)
CASHBACK
THE LAST FARM
OUR TIME IS UP SIX SHOOTER
ACHIEVEMENT IN SOUND EDITING
KING KONG
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
WAR OF THE WORLDS
ACHIEVEMENT IN SOUND MIXING
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE
KING KONG
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
WALK THE LINE
WAR OF THE WORLDS
ACHIEVEMENT IN VISUAL EFFECTS
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE Dean Wright, Bill Westenhofer, Jim Berney and Scott Farrar
KING KONG Joe Letteri, Brian Van't Hul, Christian Rivers and Richard Taylor
WAR OF THE WORLDS Dennis Muren, Pablo Helman, Randy Dutra and Daniel Sudick
Effects date so badly, but the big monkey may win this...
Oh, by the way, how long into Friday's RadioFive broadcast from Mark Kermode before he complains about Andy Serkis not being nominated for best actor? Or has he already spouted off on this?
ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Screenplay by Larry McMurtry & Diana Ossana
CAPOTE Screenplay by Dan Futterman
THE CONSTANT GARDENER Screenplay by Jeffrey Caine
A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE Screenplay by Josh Olson
MUNICH Screenplay by Tony Kushner and Eric Roth
For all the things I liked about Munich, to reward its screenplay would be the hardest to justify. I'd personally like to see History of Violence get this, but suspect it will be tight between Brokeback Mountain and Capote. TCG may have more chance in the BAFTAs...
ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
CRASH Screenplay by Paul Haggis & Bobby Moresco; Story by Paul Haggis
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK. Screenplay by George Clooney & Grant Heslov
MATCH POINT Woody Allen
THE SQUID AND THE WHALE Noah Baumbach
SYRIANA Stephen Gaghan
Nominating Woody Allen?! I don't get it... not for this. Otherwise, given I have only seen Crash it would be hard to comment (never stopped me before you say!). I'd happily see either Clooney venture rewarded, but for me Crash was good enough to win through.
So here it is in all its incomplete ingloriousness: I hope to come back to it but you know what I'm like....
The nominations:
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE
Philip Seymour Hoffman - CAPOTE
Terrence Howard - HUSTLE & FLOW
Heath Ledger - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
Joaquin Phoenix - WALK THE LINE
David Strathairn - GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK.
I still rate Strathairn, but the swing may now be behind PSH for Capote, a film I am truly looking forward to seeing. Whilst for the BAFTAs you have to take account of the home vote for Fiennes, as well as the mixed desire to pre-empt the Oscars and reward those who may not get the Oscar look-in, in the US I think this may have now become more clear-cut.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTOR IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
George Clooney - SYRIANA
Matt Dillon - CRASH
Paul Giamatti - CINDERELLA MAN
Jake Gyllenhaal - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
William Hurt - A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE
Not sure why Hurt is nominated for HoV: an old favourite back in favour with the academy? Paul Giamatti may swing this for losing out last year. Nice to see Crash getting nominations in abundance though, despite being last year's film rather than a more recent release for Oscar season.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A LEADING ROLE
Judi Dench - MRS. HENDERSON PRESENTS
Felicity Huffman - TRANSAMERICA
Keira Knightley - PRIDE & PREJUDICE
Charlize Theron - NORTH COUNTRY
Reese Witherspoon - WALK THE LINE
It seems as if Reese may be the hot favourite for this, closely followed by Felicity Huffman. It all depends on if they want to reward a musical in the acting nominations for the second year running (it's also why I don't think JP is front-runner for the actor award). If the two Brit nominations get whiff of this award I will scream "are you insane?" Prior winner Charlize Theron may lose out because of her winner status.
PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A SUPPORTING ROLE
Amy Adams - JUNEBUG
Catherine Keener - CAPOTE
Frances McDormand - NORTH COUNTRY
Rachel Weisz - THE CONSTANT GARDENER
Michelle Williams - BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
I love Catherine Keener, but the swing may be behind Rachel Weisz for this one.
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE FILM OF THE YEAR
HOWL'S MOVING CASTLE
TIM BURTON'S CORPSE BRIDE
WALLACE & GROMIT IN THE CURSE OF THE WERE-RABBIT
Tough, tough, tough but my heart goes with W&G of course...
ACHIEVEMENT IN ART DIRECTION
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK Jim Bissell (Art Direction); Jan Pascale (Set Decoration)
HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE Stuart Craig (Art Direction); Stephenie McMillan (Set Decoration)
KING KONG Grant Major (Art Direction); Dan Hennah and Simon Bright (Set Decoration)
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA John Myhre (Art Direction); Gretchen Rau (Set Decoration)
PRIDE & PREJUDICE Sarah Greenwood (Art Direction); Katie Spencer (Set Decoration)
ACHIEVEMENT IN CINEMATOGRAPHY
BATMAN BEGINS Wally Pfister
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Rodrigo Prieto
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK Robert Elswit
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA Dion Beebe
THE NEW WORLD Emmanuel Lubezki
The look of a film can be so important, and all the director's vision in the world will not help if those making it look good (set, photography) are not equally matched to the director. In an age where we have grown used to colour, working in black and white always seems to look spectacularly wonderful on-screen, but getting it to look that way isn't easy: after all, we're not seeing the world in bloack and white through our eyes, and we're less used to critically comparing different black and white cinematography. Would it be a cop-out to reward the work then in GN&GL? I don't think so. Malik always seems to inspire good visuals though, so nice to see that getting a nod. I do admit though that Batman Begins did look amazing...
ACHIEVEMENT IN COSTUME DESIGN
CHARLIE AND THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
MRS. HENDERSON PRESENTS
PRIDE & PREJUDICE
WALK THE LINE
ACHIEVEMENT IN DIRECTING
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Ang Lee
CAPOTE Bennett Miller
CRASH Paul Haggis
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK George Clooney
MUNICH Steven Spielberg
Horrid to predict this one, except to say that I doubt Spielberg will scoop direction for Munich: but this is a very strong list with merit (or expectations of merit for those I've not yet seen) across the board in the category.
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE
DARWIN'S NIGHTMARE
ENRON: THE SMARTEST GUYS IN THE ROOM
MARCH OF THE PENGUINS
MURDERBALL
STREET FIGHT
BEST DOCUMENTARY SHORT SUBJECT
THE DEATH OF KEVIN CARTER: CASUALTY OF THE BANG BANG CLUB
GOD SLEEPS IN RWANDA
THE MUSHROOM CLUB
A NOTE OF TRIUMPH: THE GOLDEN AGE OF NORMAN CORWIN
ACHIEVEMENT IN FILM EDITING
CINDERELLA MAN Mike Hill and Dan Hanley
THE CONSTANT GARDENER Claire Simpson
CRASH Hughes Winborne
MUNICH Michael Kahn
WALK THE LINE Michael McCusker
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM OF THE YEAR
DON'T TELL
JOYEUX NOèL
PARADISE NOW
SOPHIE SCHOLL - THE FINAL DAYS
TSOTSI
ACHIEVEMENT IN MAKEUP
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE CINDERELLA MAN
STAR WARS: EPISODE III REVENGE OF THE SITH
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SCORE)
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
THE CONSTANT GARDENER
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
MUNICH
PRIDE & PREJUDICE
ACHIEVEMENT IN MUSIC WRITTEN FOR MOTION PICTURES (ORIGINAL SONG)
"In the Deep" - CRASH
"It's Hard Out Here for a Pimp" - HUSTLE & FLOW
"Travelin' Thru" - TRANSAMERICA
BEST MOTION PICTURE OF THE YEAR
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN
CAPOTE
CRASH
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK
MUNICH
There was much speculation that Munich would not make much indentation on the Oscars this year - still at least they seemed to get the DVDs out to the voters. I suspect the weight is still behind Brokeback Mountain, though again this is a strong list.
BEST ANIMATED SHORT FILM
BADGERED THE MOON AND THE SON: AN IMAGINED CONVERSATION
THE MYSTERIOUS GEOGRAPHIC EXPLORATIONS OF JASPER MORELLO 9 ONE MAN BAND
BEST LIVE ACTION SHORT FILM
AUSREISSER (THE RUNAWAY)
CASHBACK
THE LAST FARM
OUR TIME IS UP SIX SHOOTER
ACHIEVEMENT IN SOUND EDITING
KING KONG
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
WAR OF THE WORLDS
ACHIEVEMENT IN SOUND MIXING
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE
KING KONG
MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA
WALK THE LINE
WAR OF THE WORLDS
ACHIEVEMENT IN VISUAL EFFECTS
THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE Dean Wright, Bill Westenhofer, Jim Berney and Scott Farrar
KING KONG Joe Letteri, Brian Van't Hul, Christian Rivers and Richard Taylor
WAR OF THE WORLDS Dennis Muren, Pablo Helman, Randy Dutra and Daniel Sudick
Effects date so badly, but the big monkey may win this...
Oh, by the way, how long into Friday's RadioFive broadcast from Mark Kermode before he complains about Andy Serkis not being nominated for best actor? Or has he already spouted off on this?
ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN Screenplay by Larry McMurtry & Diana Ossana
CAPOTE Screenplay by Dan Futterman
THE CONSTANT GARDENER Screenplay by Jeffrey Caine
A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE Screenplay by Josh Olson
MUNICH Screenplay by Tony Kushner and Eric Roth
For all the things I liked about Munich, to reward its screenplay would be the hardest to justify. I'd personally like to see History of Violence get this, but suspect it will be tight between Brokeback Mountain and Capote. TCG may have more chance in the BAFTAs...
ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
CRASH Screenplay by Paul Haggis & Bobby Moresco; Story by Paul Haggis
GOOD NIGHT, AND GOOD LUCK. Screenplay by George Clooney & Grant Heslov
MATCH POINT Woody Allen
THE SQUID AND THE WHALE Noah Baumbach
SYRIANA Stephen Gaghan
Nominating Woody Allen?! I don't get it... not for this. Otherwise, given I have only seen Crash it would be hard to comment (never stopped me before you say!). I'd happily see either Clooney venture rewarded, but for me Crash was good enough to win through.
Cairngorm pictures! [thanks to George]

Cairngorm Summit

Descending from Cairngorm
Thes magnificent pictures were taken by George this past weekend on his LONG hike. They were just too beautiful to not share with you, being so darn atmospheric you almost feel as if you are floating on top of the world looking at them: with his permission they are here for your delight.
Sunday, January 29, 2006
Cinema day: Munich and Hidden
Went to town yesterday and saw Munich at the Cornerhouse followed by Hidden at the Broadway (the latter will hopefully not be forced to close due to it stupidity at being repeatedly stung for selling alcohol to under-age drinkers: trust me, it will NOT survive losing its licence).
Anyway, the movies. Despite the complaints, we actually found Munich far more satisfying than we expected and at least worth seeing, even if the weeks documentaries told the narrative more effectively and 'truthfully'. What no-one can surely dispute is that Munich is Eric Bana's film through and through. Bana, whom I have otherwise only seen in the magnificently dark and bleakly hysterical Chopper, dominates the film. As Ben Marshall remarks in this week's Guardian Guide article:
One great thing about seeing a film like Munich is you can pretty much predict the trailers: unlike works less identifiably 'art-house lite', where you can sometimes sit in wonderment at the bizarrely inappropriate selection of trailers on show, here it was obvious what we would get. The cinema had clearly pegged us as liberal/left social thinkers: Syriana and Good Night and Good Luck it is then, with Flight 93 thrown in for good measure. I think at least the Clooney ventures will be getting our bums on seats, and I have no objections to repeated screenings of those trailers.
So to Hidden, which has garnered plaudits from many corners. It certainly is worthwhile, with the central performances being especially wonderful. I'm rather fond of Daniel Auteuil, being a huge fan of La fille sur la pont. This is another great performance from this woundedly laconic actor, but that is not to underestimate his co-stars. the cinematography of Christian Berger is stunning, and the movement from 'video' to film is seamless in an appropriately creepy way. As you would expect from writer / director Michael Haneke, there are at least two truly uncomfortable scenes of unexpected violence which are central to the film. Shocking and disturbing, they highlight the various ideas and incarnations of what is 'hidden.'
Most beautifully, in an age which demands 'closure', the film ends on a bleakly unresolved note which, even for a pretty substantial art-house cinema audience drew a collective mental gasp of "huh?!" when the credits started to roll: it was as if the entire audience was unwittingly dragged into admitting they had expected resolution and instead found themselves resisting the urge to yell "that's it? that's how you're ending it?!" A good thing.
On a more superficial level can I say I loved the apartment that Auteil and Binoche shared: books on show and lots of them! That's what I ultimately want for my sitting room!
Anyway, the movies. Despite the complaints, we actually found Munich far more satisfying than we expected and at least worth seeing, even if the weeks documentaries told the narrative more effectively and 'truthfully'. What no-one can surely dispute is that Munich is Eric Bana's film through and through. Bana, whom I have otherwise only seen in the magnificently dark and bleakly hysterical Chopper, dominates the film. As Ben Marshall remarks in this week's Guardian Guide article:
You leave the cinema convinced that without this actor as his lead, Spielberg might just have ended up with the world's most expensive remake of Death Wish.Bana is brooding and tormented in a truly strong and moderately silent style: a definite cinematic throwback. Does the film work? I think so: whatever its faults as a documentary history, there is a compelling narrative here, albeit one effectively strung on one character. Some of the dialogue is clunky, but at least in one scene, knowingly so:
Daphna: We should stay at home.Overall, I would say that - as in so many cases of dramas 'inspired by real events' - that if you're looking for an accurate portrayal of events, go to a documentary [the Coen's played with this well in Fargo of course!]; if you want a human narrative that may draw you into the real life events, this fiction may be a start. It is problematic, but that is as much to do with the difficult subject matter and the nature of fictionalisation than with Spielberg. Blaming him is not the solution.
Avner: You are the only home I ever had.
Daphna: ...
[laughs]
Daphna: This is so corny.
Avner: What? That took a lot for me to say!
Daphna: Why did I have to marry a sentimentalist? You're ruining my life.
Avner: [to their newborn baby] Your mother's teasing me.
One great thing about seeing a film like Munich is you can pretty much predict the trailers: unlike works less identifiably 'art-house lite', where you can sometimes sit in wonderment at the bizarrely inappropriate selection of trailers on show, here it was obvious what we would get. The cinema had clearly pegged us as liberal/left social thinkers: Syriana and Good Night and Good Luck it is then, with Flight 93 thrown in for good measure. I think at least the Clooney ventures will be getting our bums on seats, and I have no objections to repeated screenings of those trailers.
So to Hidden, which has garnered plaudits from many corners. It certainly is worthwhile, with the central performances being especially wonderful. I'm rather fond of Daniel Auteuil, being a huge fan of La fille sur la pont. This is another great performance from this woundedly laconic actor, but that is not to underestimate his co-stars. the cinematography of Christian Berger is stunning, and the movement from 'video' to film is seamless in an appropriately creepy way. As you would expect from writer / director Michael Haneke, there are at least two truly uncomfortable scenes of unexpected violence which are central to the film. Shocking and disturbing, they highlight the various ideas and incarnations of what is 'hidden.'
Most beautifully, in an age which demands 'closure', the film ends on a bleakly unresolved note which, even for a pretty substantial art-house cinema audience drew a collective mental gasp of "huh?!" when the credits started to roll: it was as if the entire audience was unwittingly dragged into admitting they had expected resolution and instead found themselves resisting the urge to yell "that's it? that's how you're ending it?!" A good thing.
On a more superficial level can I say I loved the apartment that Auteil and Binoche shared: books on show and lots of them! That's what I ultimately want for my sitting room!
Friday, January 27, 2006
So many good posts out there: these just from one site
Try here for something on the weirdness of books (thanks for tipping me to visit C&P again: must be all of just over a day since I was on the site...)
Circulating on blogger I was also directed to Struggling Author's wonderful 7 meme, with added David Tennant-ness
And try here if you want to find out the most hilarious dream read in ages.
Genius. Toot toot folks, off home!
Circulating on blogger I was also directed to Struggling Author's wonderful 7 meme, with added David Tennant-ness
And try here if you want to find out the most hilarious dream read in ages.
Genius. Toot toot folks, off home!
Jane Garvey and travelling home
Rob's post - belatedly caught by me - is perfect. Not only does he continue the well-deserved praise of the fantastic Jane Garvey (driving home just isn't the same without her on the radio), but he also has brilliant comments to make on drivers and accidents. I'd heard the horrors of the particular accident he mentions, but his report perfectly captures what happens
"following a coach-motorcycle interface. It opened shortly before I set off for home, and it wasn't too bad, considering, except I then got stuck in a 10-mile-Southbound tailback caused by people slowing down to look at the umpty-mile tailback on the other side. I love it when people do that. I lurve it. I want to kiss the people who do that. With my fist of wrath.Yes, because what we all need to do when there has been an accident is slow down to look: what is it with that response?! And why, despite all signs to the contrary is there always someone who is "so Important and Busy that he was confident of being let through"? I'm only amazed he wasn't driving a BMW...
The northbound problem was caused - drumroll - by a truck and something that was now spread over most of the 3 lanes. So the motorway was closed for several hours between J23 and J23a. Cars sitting behind the incident were in the for the long haul, their lights and engines switched off (apart from one - optimistic? stupid? - Audi driver, who was clearly so Important and Busy that he was confident of being let through)."
Incapacity benefit: not fully chewed but...
As I have worked - and continue to work - with disabled adults, the issue of incapacity benefit has long been a source of fury to me. Frankly, the standard of living [existence] on benefits for the vast majority of people continues to be a disgrace despite all the efforts of the Labour government to improve/clarify benefit provision. I'm being charitable there because the benefit system is an incredibly complex beast which government has the unenviable task of making the populace swallow paying taxes for in a climate where increasingly we are inadvertently [deliberately?] labelling people as deserving and undeserving poor. The current difficulties come out of long-term problems and circumstances and at this point I see no logic in 'blaming' the current Labour government for the situation any more than I would seek to shift the blame to the previous lengthier Conservative administration [7 years ain't a blip, but it's scarcely halfway to the 15 years* of the past administration in terms of social impact]: political and social systems more broadly contribute to the problem. [* UPDATE: thanks Neil for pointing out that should read 18 years; a fact I well know but must have somehow been repressing...]
Anyway, taking as the jumping off point the recent Bloggers4Labour debate, I accept that it would be a wonderful thing that "The more severely disabled people will receive a higher rate of benefit and have no obligation to look for work." Fabulous idea and far better than the ludicrous situation where people have to keep justifying themselves, experiencing loss of income and then the erratic reimbursement of benefit arrears: people who are no position to keep on doing this performance, and indeed are adversely affected by having to do so.
However, there is at least a problem there in defining "severely disabled." Do we mean those disabled people requiring 24 hour care? What kind of care? Some may nevertheless want to work in some form, but may require exceptionally specialist support from both the state in terms of getting them into suitable jobs and also employers meeting disability legislation requirements... or are we going to tell those who might fall into that category that because the new incapacity benefit deems them suitably "severely disabled" they not only are not required to look for work/to work but will not be provided with advice and assistance in working?
I'm not especially ideologically stunted enough to refuse to ignore the practicalities of government rethinking how and why the benefits system should work. However, currently the benefit system in part effectively subsidises employers paying inadequate wages to meet a certain basic standard of living and proposed plans for amending Incapacity Benefit hardly seem to address how employers will be encouraged/forced to deal with inadequate wages.
One could also look at the issue of how compulsion will operate for those deemed to be able to look for work: I was discussing this with Cloud the other night when he suggested that accepting that some claiming incapacity benefit have no desire to work [no where near as many, nor costing as much, as those defrauding the state via endless accountancy tax scams], such people will generally find ways to march through the required hoops to enable them to continue claiming. I argued that it was likely to turn out to be much more complex than that, given that the intention is reduce the bill for benefits [I hold no truck with the concept that this change to Incapacity Benefit is intended to solely reduce the costs of that one benefit: otherwise the government might as well say it is happy for the overall benefit budget to continue at the same level, just shifting it away from coming under the Incapacity budget]. I would say 'what is the compulsion and will it operate as a sliding scale or a continuous activity? That is, are we looking at: you've applied for X jobs in the last 6 months... "and was shortlisted/interviewed Y times so you can carry on claiming; "you did not get any interviews so you can only carry on claiming providing..."; "you did not get any interviews because they weren't 'appropriate' so you must now apply for A..."? Anyone who is a graduate is likely to testify to the general inability of the job centres etc to appropriately support and understand their search for work. I dread to imagine how some of the vulnerable students I have worked with in recent years, who potentially fall under Incapacity Benefit, will fare under the combined weight of the new regime and the long-term relative inability of job centres to advise the graduate sector. As Paul Leake outlined in his comment to the B4L debate "The problem for me isn't the principle ... but the practice".
B4L also said:
In the B4L comments, Tom raised the idea that cutting the benefits of the weakest went against socialist principles [it's that word!], spurring B4L to respond that what such an attitude
Much trumpeting was made in the news on how changes to the incapacity benefit in a trial project had supported a woman who had experienced mental health difficulties to come off incapacity benefit. But she was now running her own business - hardly an option that is going to be suitable for every person, let alone a substantial majority of those on incapacity benefit. And let's not kid ourselves as to how hideous the spiral of mental illness can be, nor the appalling attitudes that pervade in the workplace once it comes to actually working with or employing people with mental health problems [I've seen this in practice: one thing for employers to say they're supportive, quite another to BE supportive].
Deluded as I may be, I think government does have an obligation to ensure (1) that poverty, relative or otherwise is minimised if not eradicated, not least in this country and that people are given dignity and respect to live their lives. Ensuring opportunities to work, and assistance to participate in the workplace are but one part of that. But this leads me to (2): that government also has an obligation to ensure that employers are encouraged to pay wages appropriate to minimising/eradicating poverty, rather than their profits being subsidised by government benefits and the procedural nonsense that goes with so many of them.
Minimum income for all? Absolutely.
I now await your punches.
Anyway, taking as the jumping off point the recent Bloggers4Labour debate, I accept that it would be a wonderful thing that "The more severely disabled people will receive a higher rate of benefit and have no obligation to look for work." Fabulous idea and far better than the ludicrous situation where people have to keep justifying themselves, experiencing loss of income and then the erratic reimbursement of benefit arrears: people who are no position to keep on doing this performance, and indeed are adversely affected by having to do so.
However, there is at least a problem there in defining "severely disabled." Do we mean those disabled people requiring 24 hour care? What kind of care? Some may nevertheless want to work in some form, but may require exceptionally specialist support from both the state in terms of getting them into suitable jobs and also employers meeting disability legislation requirements... or are we going to tell those who might fall into that category that because the new incapacity benefit deems them suitably "severely disabled" they not only are not required to look for work/to work but will not be provided with advice and assistance in working?
I'm not especially ideologically stunted enough to refuse to ignore the practicalities of government rethinking how and why the benefits system should work. However, currently the benefit system in part effectively subsidises employers paying inadequate wages to meet a certain basic standard of living and proposed plans for amending Incapacity Benefit hardly seem to address how employers will be encouraged/forced to deal with inadequate wages.
One could also look at the issue of how compulsion will operate for those deemed to be able to look for work: I was discussing this with Cloud the other night when he suggested that accepting that some claiming incapacity benefit have no desire to work [no where near as many, nor costing as much, as those defrauding the state via endless accountancy tax scams], such people will generally find ways to march through the required hoops to enable them to continue claiming. I argued that it was likely to turn out to be much more complex than that, given that the intention is reduce the bill for benefits [I hold no truck with the concept that this change to Incapacity Benefit is intended to solely reduce the costs of that one benefit: otherwise the government might as well say it is happy for the overall benefit budget to continue at the same level, just shifting it away from coming under the Incapacity budget]. I would say 'what is the compulsion and will it operate as a sliding scale or a continuous activity? That is, are we looking at: you've applied for X jobs in the last 6 months... "and was shortlisted/interviewed Y times so you can carry on claiming; "you did not get any interviews so you can only carry on claiming providing..."; "you did not get any interviews because they weren't 'appropriate' so you must now apply for A..."? Anyone who is a graduate is likely to testify to the general inability of the job centres etc to appropriately support and understand their search for work. I dread to imagine how some of the vulnerable students I have worked with in recent years, who potentially fall under Incapacity Benefit, will fare under the combined weight of the new regime and the long-term relative inability of job centres to advise the graduate sector. As Paul Leake outlined in his comment to the B4L debate "The problem for me isn't the principle ... but the practice".
B4L also said:
Nobody's saying it will be easy for many of these people to find work - especially with lingering symptoms and side-effects of their sickness - but at least a job search can begin, people have something to aim at, to train for, and can try to change their lives.I think this again somewhat misses the point, not just because of finding the right sort of work, but also the number of hours that the person could work and the level of income that could provide [see the post below for further comments on the concept of 'minimum income', an issue which B4L seems utterly prepared to ignore when he goes on to remark "If you can work, you should, even if it is for less than the JA, not least because of all the other non-wage benefits of employment as against unemployment" - I'll come back to this one shortly in this lengthy post].
In the B4L comments, Tom raised the idea that cutting the benefits of the weakest went against socialist principles [it's that word!], spurring B4L to respond that what such an attitude
demonstrate[s] is a sentimental attachment to "the weakest" without any obvious concern to offer them new opportunities, or a route out of poverty, because they are - as I suggested above - a political pawn to be used in an ideological New/Old Labour-style battle, which is far more important to its participants than the people who actually need money and jobs to live.OUCH! Needless to say, things got worse from there with B4L digging himself in deeper with this further response:
I do think sentimentalism is the right word to use when well-intentioned measures to help those who can work, and to reduce dependency, are condemned just because some - who can work and refuse to be helped, but are sheltered by their victim status - may lose out.And this, one could say, takes us to one specific aspect of the problem raised earlier in my mentioning 'deserving and undeserving poor': what the purpose of benefits actually is. There is a widespread perception that certain factions of the left effectively defend and perpetuate "victim status" upon the weakest members of society, but surely it is even worse to ignore how complex and demeaning the benefit system can be? There may be handfuls who have become immune, perhaps perversely have even come to thrive on having to navigate the benefits system 'successfully', but this says more about our attitudes towards class and (participation in) society than about the amounts of money available [we'll leave for another time debates about the impact of celebrity culture encouraging ridiculously large proportions of young people to want to "BE" famous as a career/life status/identity]. Wanting to work is not the same as being able to work, let alone the same as being able to work and earn sufficient for doing more than existing (a situation that does much more damage to self-confidence and mental health than may be believed). It is not impossible to imagine a person saying to themselves: "I'm working and I'm STILL not off benefit and all that entails because what I can earn and the working standards I have to experience are so poor that I'm still at the bottom of the social pile."
Much trumpeting was made in the news on how changes to the incapacity benefit in a trial project had supported a woman who had experienced mental health difficulties to come off incapacity benefit. But she was now running her own business - hardly an option that is going to be suitable for every person, let alone a substantial majority of those on incapacity benefit. And let's not kid ourselves as to how hideous the spiral of mental illness can be, nor the appalling attitudes that pervade in the workplace once it comes to actually working with or employing people with mental health problems [I've seen this in practice: one thing for employers to say they're supportive, quite another to BE supportive].
Deluded as I may be, I think government does have an obligation to ensure (1) that poverty, relative or otherwise is minimised if not eradicated, not least in this country and that people are given dignity and respect to live their lives. Ensuring opportunities to work, and assistance to participate in the workplace are but one part of that. But this leads me to (2): that government also has an obligation to ensure that employers are encouraged to pay wages appropriate to minimising/eradicating poverty, rather than their profits being subsidised by government benefits and the procedural nonsense that goes with so many of them.
Minimum income for all? Absolutely.
I now await your punches.
Holocaust Memorial Day
Today. Pause, reflect, learn from this.
Anyone else watch the programme on Channel 4 by wonderful Hardeep Singh Kohli debating why we need a Holocaust Memorial Day? What I found so profoundly moving was how he made his case exploring the perils and pitfalls of Britain's adoption of Holocaust Memorial Day only to find himself somewhat undone by confronting the historically preserved realities of the Jewish Holocaust. A very good programme presenting the evolution of a debate.
Anyone else watch the programme on Channel 4 by wonderful Hardeep Singh Kohli debating why we need a Holocaust Memorial Day? What I found so profoundly moving was how he made his case exploring the perils and pitfalls of Britain's adoption of Holocaust Memorial Day only to find himself somewhat undone by confronting the historically preserved realities of the Jewish Holocaust. A very good programme presenting the evolution of a debate.
Thursday, January 26, 2006
Incapacity benefit: I'm chewing over and mentally writing a response to this topic
In the meantime, some 'debates' and rants at Bloggers4labour.
What's wrong with jazz?
Rob Buckley doesn't like jazz. I think that his problem may be akin to one I had in my earlier years: 1) I thought jazz was just one thing and 2) I wasn't ready for jazz, of any kind.
It's hard to imagine a world without jazz, not least because of how it bleeds into so many other genres of music: blues and funk to name just two. Over the years I have known many people who proclaimed a 'hatred' for jazz, and eventually all have been teased out of their way of defining jazz into admitting they liked certain pieces of music, performances, performers or styles, not realising their place in the world of jazz. I think as well what doesn't help is record stores categorising music: jazz, world, easy listening, metal, urban (whaaaat?!!!) etc etc. Why not just alphabetical by artiste, mixing all styles together? Ttake away the predictability of only liking particular types of music and dismissing all variations within others.
It's hard to imagine a world without jazz, not least because of how it bleeds into so many other genres of music: blues and funk to name just two. Over the years I have known many people who proclaimed a 'hatred' for jazz, and eventually all have been teased out of their way of defining jazz into admitting they liked certain pieces of music, performances, performers or styles, not realising their place in the world of jazz. I think as well what doesn't help is record stores categorising music: jazz, world, easy listening, metal, urban (whaaaat?!!!) etc etc. Why not just alphabetical by artiste, mixing all styles together? Ttake away the predictability of only liking particular types of music and dismissing all variations within others.
What does it mean to BE gay?
Was Simon Hughes being hypocritical when he recently denied to the Independent that he was gay, only to 'come out' to The Sun (of all papers!) and state: "I am perfectly willing to say that I have had both homosexual and heterosexual relationships in the past"? Is he just 'bisexual' as this Guardian blog comment reports?
On balance, I suspect that his politician's soul got the better of him here and that there is a degree of hypocrisy to what he has said previously and now. HOWEVER, as is typical for the British attitude to sex and sexual activities, I do think that there is not necessarily a contradiction per se in Hughes stating he is "not gay" and admitting to having had homosexual relationships. Is the tag of bisexuality is sufficiently adequate?
In the excellent book Gay New York, writer George Chauncey argues that identification as 'being gay' would have made no sense to those in pre-WWII America, and many men would have engaged in sexual acts with other men without this precluding them from 'being heterosexual' or even restricting them to 'being bisexual'. I don't think that the passing of time should dictate that these problems with 'being' something have been resolved.
Additionally, there is the issue of how, or whether, the status of heterosexuality is implicitly privileged: given that seemingly one gay relationship or act can undermine your full identification as heterosexual, does this suggest that actually homosexuality is the privileged action since it has such an impact on identification? I would argue that the peception of such binaries as heterosexual/homosexual (black/white; male/female) is not so clear-cut: the pairing is not perceived to be of equal status. The homosexual act has the impact that it does on clear identification of heterosexuality not because homosexuality is privileged but precisely because it is perceived as so OTHER, because it taints the security of identifying the privileged group as "pure" / "normal" *. Moreover, the identification of biexuality does not entirely resolve such dichotomies, as is explored in Marjorie Garber's book Vice Versa: bisexuality is "not just another sexual orientation but rather a sexuality that undoes sexual orientation as a category."
* Please note that I do NOT believe that heterosexuality is a state of being that is "pure" / "normal", any more than I would see women as secondary to men, or those of non-white races as secondary to whites.
On balance, I suspect that his politician's soul got the better of him here and that there is a degree of hypocrisy to what he has said previously and now. HOWEVER, as is typical for the British attitude to sex and sexual activities, I do think that there is not necessarily a contradiction per se in Hughes stating he is "not gay" and admitting to having had homosexual relationships. Is the tag of bisexuality is sufficiently adequate?
In the excellent book Gay New York, writer George Chauncey argues that identification as 'being gay' would have made no sense to those in pre-WWII America, and many men would have engaged in sexual acts with other men without this precluding them from 'being heterosexual' or even restricting them to 'being bisexual'. I don't think that the passing of time should dictate that these problems with 'being' something have been resolved.
Additionally, there is the issue of how, or whether, the status of heterosexuality is implicitly privileged: given that seemingly one gay relationship or act can undermine your full identification as heterosexual, does this suggest that actually homosexuality is the privileged action since it has such an impact on identification? I would argue that the peception of such binaries as heterosexual/homosexual (black/white; male/female) is not so clear-cut: the pairing is not perceived to be of equal status. The homosexual act has the impact that it does on clear identification of heterosexuality not because homosexuality is privileged but precisely because it is perceived as so OTHER, because it taints the security of identifying the privileged group as "pure" / "normal" *. Moreover, the identification of biexuality does not entirely resolve such dichotomies, as is explored in Marjorie Garber's book Vice Versa: bisexuality is "not just another sexual orientation but rather a sexuality that undoes sexual orientation as a category."
* Please note that I do NOT believe that heterosexuality is a state of being that is "pure" / "normal", any more than I would see women as secondary to men, or those of non-white races as secondary to whites.
Wednesday, January 25, 2006
Changing faces
I'm with Shakespeare's Sis on the response to this story.
Personally I think that plastic surgery is largely a con on a willing but often deluded public; those who work in the cosmetic end of the business are mostly exploiting a tragic sense of vanity.
Personally I think that plastic surgery is largely a con on a willing but often deluded public; those who work in the cosmetic end of the business are mostly exploiting a tragic sense of vanity.
Chris Penn
Wow. Chris Penn really wasn't that old. Heard this on the radio as I came in to work today.
Though the BBC can't work out how old he was (this story currently says 40; the radio reported it as 43).
We rewatched True Romance recently, and Mulholland Falls is another favourite film of ours: beyond his most well-known performance in Resevoir Dogs, he was still a fine actor in these genre pictures (not a field to be underestimated).
Though the BBC can't work out how old he was (this story currently says 40; the radio reported it as 43).
We rewatched True Romance recently, and Mulholland Falls is another favourite film of ours: beyond his most well-known performance in Resevoir Dogs, he was still a fine actor in these genre pictures (not a field to be underestimated).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)