Sunday, July 18, 2010

Rolling my eyes at the "I write like..." meme

Okay: first up I put in the review I wrote for Maureen Carter's "Death Line".

Turns out I write like Edgar Allan Poe.

Then I put in my review for the recent Doctor Who season finale.

Turns out I write like David Foster Wallace.

Then I tried my review for 'The Silence'.

Seems I'm H.P. Lovecraft.

I tried my piece on reading and not reading.

I'm actually Cory Doctorow.

If I put in the Big Session 2010 review...

I'm back to being H.P. Lovecraft again.

So here's the thing:

How many famous authors is it actually drawing on to be able to 'define' writing styles? There is a nice critique at Tea Berry-Blue which neatly quizzes the 'analyzer' with extracts from a variety of authors - including a range of female writers.

Who'd have thought? Turns out they mostly write like white male authors.

An interesting exercise, but perhaps not one to take too seriously.

2 comments:

  1. See, this is why I've given up on those quizzes on Facebook. They're like this, remarkably unrevelatory, and rather reminiscent of the "personalized" recommendation at Amazon (which seems to think I like all horror films because I once ordered a DVD of the 1963 version of The Haunting). My results were remarkably similiar to yours; I chose random entries from early blog posts, recent ones, and those from about a year ago. Rubbish.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hmm, have you looked in a mirror recently and found out who you really are?

    ReplyDelete